Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie - Brooklyn, New York

Kam C.

Their small sized Keylime pie definitely hit the spot, and was priced fairly.

Not too sweet, perfect lime flavoring that was not overly citrusy. Perfect to share!

Mi Z.

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is a true gem for those who appreciate a balanced dessert. As someone without a sweet tooth, I found their key lime pie to be absolutely perfect. The tartness of the key lime filling is refreshing and well-balanced, offering just the right amount of sweetness without being overwhelming. The crust is perfectly crisp and buttery, complementing the creamy texture of the filling. It's a delightful treat that leaves you satisfied without the sugar overload. If you're looking for a dessert that's flavorful and perfectly balanced, Steve's Authentic CLASSIC Key Lime Pie is a must-try

Bianca

The key lime pie is phenomenal, but the swingle is out of this world. I traveled to Key West last year and had key lime pie there for the first time. When I came back to NY, I kept trying to find one that could meet my expectations. Recently, I found Steve’s Key Lime Pie. I came by 2 days ago for the first time and had to come back today and grab pies for the entire family. The swingle is an absolute game changer. As someone who is obsessed with chocolate and key lime pie, this is THE best dessert. Absolutely obsessed…P.S. I’d love some vanilla bean whipped cream to go along with it!

Benjamin J.

Overrated, sadly. I love key lime pie and have ordered it in dozens of places. This bakery has a uniquely soft crust but the pie is not as good as I've had elsewhere, and isn't served with whipped cream.

A D. N.

We went for a walk to Louis Valentino Park and Pier, because of the filming of the Netflix series POSE. The Keylime popsicle was a nice authentic experience! Which made the walk complete. We took the lime-raspberry variant and it was really great. Big, cold, crispy and soft. Not too sweet or sour. A good price-quality ratio. If you are in the area you should make a stop.

Jon (.

It is a very cute little shop that sells delicious keylime pie and the popular chocolate dipped keylime pie popsicle. Sweet on the outside and tart on the inside. The staff was incredibly friendly and nice. There are benches for you to sit and enjoy, but also around the corner is a cute park to enjoy the views of the statue of liberty 🗽

Ruth L.

I wish it were closer by. Their key lime pie puts all others to shame. It is divine. And I always devour a swingle when I visit.

Vivianne B.

I've been here a few times. I'm not really a pie person but Steve's Key Lime Pies can definitely change that. The pies come in various sizes. The Key Lime filling is tart with the right amount of sweetness and the crust is delicious. Lately I've gotten the Swingle which is a frozen small version of the pie, on a stick. It has the Key Lime filling and crust and it also has Raspberry and it is covered in either Chocolate or White Chocolate. I've had both. They are 😋. I haven't been inside the store since the 1st time I was there. It was small but the decor was cool. Since then I order at the window and sit at the picnic tables they have outside. You can also take it to Louis J. Valentino Park, which is just a step or two away. The prices are fair. I highly recommend this as a stop in Red Hook. I do not know the person in the pic but I wanted to show the outside of Steve's.