Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

Lisa M.

Excellent experience at Anthonys Coal Fired Pizza this weekend. Had to try their pizzas of course but their fresh in house made meatballs got me. I will order those every time (and I'm italian) so soft so fresh and such a good blend of spices! Little Ricotta on the side, yum 😋

Ask for Shane, he made me a mystery drink that was absolutely delicious.Based on like questions, he asked me about what I liked. It was kind of like an orange martini with basil and something else in it.But he is definitely a great server, very friendly and very timely. Both food and service were top notch!

And during the week they have specials, I found out about and happy hour stuff so definitely worth a stop!!

Why won't it post my photos Google?

Crystal R.

It was amazing! Our food was delicious. It was a great price we were genuinely surprised by our bill. Great value. They could be charging a lot more. The staff seemed genuinely happy to be working there and super great!

Sarah S.

This place is actually amazing. The food is to die for! Our waiter was a total sweetheart, his name was Shane, he was absolutely polite in every way. It was nice to be able to actually get sparkling water with my meal.

Portion sizes are large, I brought the majority of my meal home, but I'm more than happy to have more later. Which I had the Alfredo with chicken and artichokes; adding artichokes is truly unique and delicious. I do suggest trying this establishment.

Precision T. M. G.

On November 11, 2024, my guest and I stopped by Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza to take part in their Veterans Day event, where they provided a free whole cheese pizza to veterans. After placing the order, it didn’t take long for the pizza to arrive, fresh out of the oven and perfectly cooked.

I really appreciate Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza for honoring military heroes with this thoughtful gesture. The take-out pizza was delicious, and the quick service made the experience even better. It's heartening to see a business support veterans in such a meaningful way.

Shyanne L.

We came during happy hour. We purchased a small pizza, meatballs and wings with a dry rub. We didn’t get drinks just water and the bill came to $33. The food was fantastic. The meatballs were juicy and the sauce was phenomenal. The wings had their dry rub and it was sweet with a heat at the end but not enough to deter me and I am not a person who likes super spicy food. The pizza was delicious!!!!

The picture of the pizza was all we had left!!!

meg S.

First time here. The pizza was incredible 10/10, meatballs 10/10, and sausage and pepper sandwich also 10/10! service 10/10! Our server (Shane) was so nice, and when my 1 year old started to get restless he gave her a dough ball to keep her entertained. A simple gesture but super thoughtful - something we won’t forget! Will be back for sure 🙂

The H.

Well The Hood made his way to Monroeville Pa! Stopping at the coal pizza to try it. Well… the food was good had some white pizza and wings with dry rub ( recommended by our server, wings that is). Not a fan of the dry rubs but this wasn’t bad… Th e pizza was burnt on the edges but it’s their style but it was still good. Had spinach artichoke dip and it was great! Got a chopped salad also and it was delicious! Recommend both! So overall food was good. Service- excellent! He kept an eye on us and checked often if needed anything! Atmosphere- nice lots of pics of past people you’ll see when you go. And The Hood recommends you go! So with that The Hood says be kind and keep eating and trying new things you never know when you’ll find your next favorite food! And you know you should follow The Hood see ya soon!

George

Fantastic pizza! Far superior in flavor unlike that Slice of New York place on down the road in Murrysville. I love this place and I'm sure you will too. Fresh tasting sauce, generous amount of cheese and the smoke flavor from the coals can't be beat. I love this place!