The Main Street Creamery - Wellsboro, Pennsylvania

Honest R.

Atmosphere- 4 stars- located in an old stately two story house on Main Street- this ice cream shop claims to have Homemade Ice Cream. Beautiful inside with hardwood floors and a feel of early 20th century America. There is an old fashioned soda bar in a separate room and ofcourse the ice cream parlor in an adjacent room. Some seating inside or you could sit outside on the front porch and people watch.

Service- 3 stars- young lady behind the counter was friendly but when you pay she flips the payment screen and says if you want to leave a tip you can. This is a pet peeve of mine to be constantly expected to tip and I find it inappropriate to basically ask for one.

Food- 4 stars- not sure if this is actually Homemade ice cream but either way it was still really good. I got the salted caramel Kit Kat which I have never seen. I enjoyed it while sitting out on the front porch.

Emily E.

They don't charge you for the aromatherapy you receive by walking into this place. It is heavenly.
The staff are wonderful: courteous, friendly, and prompt.
The interior js filled with warm natural wood tones and comfy places to sit.
I felt like I was in a day spa instead of getting ice cream.
The ice cream was delicious: well balanced, not too hard, generous portions. I happily ruined my appetite for "real lunch food"- sometimes, as adults, these are the choices we make.
Flavors tried: strawberry cheesecake & butterfinger.
We did not get to try the floats (pictured) but we really wanted to!

Carolyn Y.

This is one of the best ice cream parlors I’ve been to. None of the hype that the big city chains offer, but the high quality ingredients jump out at you! The lemon honeycomb ice cream was life changing for me! This shop is worth the detour!

Diane S.

Stopped in after dinner because we'd heard good things. Cute place with indoor, outdoor, and porch seating. Lots of flavors to choose from and the three scoops in a waffle bowl were outstanding. The girls behind the counter were all very professional and friendly. A long line of customers came in after us. Please stop in if you like ice cream!

Maria P.

I had the cherry cheesecake flavor and hubby got banana split . Mine was very icey - crunchy and not much flavor but my husband really liked his banana split - different strokes i guess. The prices were very reasonable but I prefer Dairy Queen. Last note - they have wet nuts - for banana splits only

AmyEG1988

Ice cream is so good every time! Friendly service and everything from cones, sundaes, to milkshakes. Flavors are delicious and beautiful place to sit down outside or inside. Has a lot of charm in the building it is located in.

Kayt M.

Amazing flavors! Almost no one has banana icecream or other unique flavors so this was such a treat that I went back a 2nd time! The cookie monster and the PB butterfinger flavors are genius (and delicious). A must visit! The building is also historic and beautiful.

Lacey F.

The ice cream was AMAZING! They had this lemon honeycomb ice cream which was the best ice cream I have ever had IN MY LIFE. The only thing I was not too fond of was the marshmallow topping. I thought it came toasted, but I wasn’t and there was way too much. Next time I would just go without it because the ice cream was so amazing on its own!